Spaghetti Ice Cream Inspired by Buddy The Elf

What’s Up, Hungry People

We’re officially only a few days away from Christmas – that means that I’m cozied up by the fire with a cup of cocoa, and I’m ready to watch holiday movies until Santa slides down the chimney.

One of my all-time favorite Christmas movies has to be Elf. It’s hard to believe that this movie is nearly two decades old and still gets quoted (nearly daily, if you live in my household). The story follows Buddy the Elf, who was found by Santa and raised by the elves at the North Pole. When he finds out that he’s actually not an elf – a fact highlighted by Buddy’s inability to produce toys at the same pace as other elves – he is determined to find his human father, who lives in a “magical place” known as New York City.

Armed with endless enthusiasm and a love for all things Christmas, Buddy navigates the big city, reconnects with his family, and spreads holiday cheer to everyone he meets. With its mix of humor, charm, and holiday spirit, Elf has become a beloved classic for families everywhere.

Buddy The Elf’s Spaghetti

While living with his dad in New York, Buddy tries to make breakfast that includes spaghetti and tomato sauce… plus candy, candy canes, candy corn and syrup – the four main food groups according the elves! While his dad isn’t super excited about the sugary mix, Buddy eats it with gusto (it’s his favorite, afterall).

I decided that I wanted to make a real-life version of this dish, but instead of wasting real spaghetti, I decided to turn the dish into dessert and make spaghettieis!

Spaghettieis is a quirky German dessert that takes ice cream to the next level by mimicking the look of a classic plate of spaghetti. Created in the late 1960s by Dario Fontanella, a German-Italian ice cream maker from Mannheim, this playful treat was born out of a stroke of creativity – and maybe a little homesickness for Italian cuisine. The dish uses vanilla ice cream pressed through a potato ricer to create “spaghetti” strands, topped with strawberry sauce “tomato sauce” and grated white chocolate “parmesan.” Initially meant to surprise customers, Spaghettieis quickly became a hit, winning over dessert lovers for its whimsical design and delicious taste. Today, it’s a staple at German ice cream parlors and a favorite for kids and adults alike.

Here’s What You Need

I’d like to think this dessert version of spaghetti would have blown Buddy’s mind!

• Vanilla ice cream: The base for your faux spaghetti strands, creamy and soft enough to press through a ricer.
• Cool Whip topping: Forms the “snow balls” at the center of the ice cream.
• Strawberry sauce: Doubles as the “tomato sauce” for this sweet take on spaghetti.
• Candy: Whatever your favorites are; these add a personal, colorful touch to the toppings.
• Candy canes: Lightly crushed for a festive crunch and a hint of peppermint.
• Candy corn: A whimsical pop of color and sweetness in your candy pile.
• Maple syrup: Drizzle this on for a Buddy-approved sweet finish.
• Chocolate Pop-Tarts: Crushed to create chocolatey crumbs that mimic parmesan cheese vibes.
• Chocolate syrup: Extra chocolaty goodness for the ultimate holiday indulgence.
• Christmas sprinkles: Adds some holiday sparkle and cheer to your “spaghetti.”
• Marshmallows: Pillowy soft bites that add a wintery snowball feel to your plate.
• Chocolate candy: Another layer of chocolaty decadence to bring it all together.

Let’s… Spread Some Holiday Cheer!

First things first – prep time! All the ingredients (except the ice cream) need to chill out in the fridge for at least an hour. Even room temperature ingredients will cause the final dish to melt rapidly.

Meanwhile, your plate, potato ricer, and ice cream scoop go in the freezer. Why all this chilling? Because melted ice cream is not the vibe here, and Buddy would agree: it’s all about keeping the “spaghetti” looking perfect.

Soften Your Ice Cream

When it’s time to get started, grab the ice cream from the freezer and let it sit out for 15–30 minutes. Keep an eye on it, though – if it gets too soft, it’ll turn into soup. You’re looking for that sweet spot where the ice cream is stirrable but still firm enough to hold its shape. Think toothpaste consistency (but way tastier, obviously). If it starts getting too melty, pop it back in the freezer to firm up again.

Shape the “Snow Balls”

While your ice cream is doing its softening thing, grab the Cool Whip. Use your chilled plate and scoop out 2–4 fluffy balls of Cool Whip, plopping them right in the center of the plate. These are the base of your winter wonderland. Toss the plate back into the freezer so everything stays cold and frosty while you prep the next step.

Create the “Spaghetti”

Now, the fun part! Fill the potato ricer about halfway with softened ice cream—don’t overdo it, or you’ll have an ice cream avalanche on your hands. Press the ice cream through the ricer and let the “spaghetti” strands flow over the Cool Whip snowballs like a delicious cascade.

If you’re feeling fancy, swirl the strands around a bit for that authentic pasta look. Once everything’s in place, freeze the spaghettieis for at least 30 minutes to let it set (or keep it there until you’re ready to show off your creation). While you absolutely can eat it right away, if you add the toppings too quickly, the ice cream will rapidly melt and lose the spaghetti-noodle effect.

Top It Off and Serve

When it’s time to serve, channel your inner Buddy the Elf. Grab that strawberry sauce and drizzle it over the top like faux tomato sauce.

Then, it’s topping time! Add candy canes, marshmallows, syrup, crushed Pop-Tarts, chocolate syrup, and whatever else makes your sugar-loving heart happy.

Tips for Buddy-Worthy Success

• Keep everything cold: Don’t skip the chilling step for your tools and ingredients. Room temperature items will melt the ice cream very quickly.
• Don’t rush the ice cream softening: Let it soften naturally on the counter. Microwaving will work in a pinch but don’t overdo it.
• Work in batches: If your potato ricer is small, don’t cram too much ice cream in at once. Overflow is messy and will ruin the look of your “spaghetti.”
• Get creative with toppings: This is the perfect excuse to clean out your candy stash. Anything sweet goes!
• Serve quickly: Once assembled, this dish melts fast. Have everyone ready to dig in before you start adding the toppings or let them choose their own!

Common Questions About Buddy’s “Spaghetti”

• Can I use a different ice cream flavor? Not really if you want to stay true to the “spaghetti” effect. Plain vanilla ice cream works best – any additional fillings or ingredients won’t go through the ricer.
• What if I don’t have a potato ricer? You can try a garlic press for mini spaghetti strands, or get crafty with a piping bag and a small round tip – but if you go the baggie route, go SLOW or else you’re likely to pop the bag.
• How long can I keep this in the freezer before serving? You can prep it up to 48 hours in advance. Just keep it tightly covered to prevent freezer burn.
• Can I skip some of the toppings? Of course! But Buddy might shed a single syrupy tear. The more, the merrier with this dessert.
• What’s the best way to crush candy canes? Toss them in a zip-top bag and whack them with a rolling pin. It’s oddly therapeutic!

This holiday dessert is a playful way to bring some Christmas cheer to the table while nodding to one of the most iconic scenes from Elf. As everyone digs in, they’ll be delighted by the whimsical look and over-the-top sweetness of this “spaghetti” dish. It’s a great excuse to gather the family, pop on your favorite holiday movie, and make some unforgettable memories.

Don’t forget to pile on the toppings like Buddy would – after all, there’s no such thing as too much syrup. Happy Holidays and happy eating, Hungry People!

Judy’s Hot Chocolate Recipe from The Santa Clause

How to Make “Who Hash” from The Grinch

Astrid’s Yaknog from How To Train Your Dragon: Gift of the Night Fury | HTTYD Inspired Recipes